Home
 »  Community
 »  Blogs
 »  Its_all_about_the_Bees_Knees
 »  Magnet Therapy?
 |  Create Your Blog
View all Blogs |  Go to the Forums

It's all about the Bee's Knees
By: spark


<< November 2009 >>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30

 Blog Entries

Life after knee surgery - Dec 23
Having never undergone any major surgery since I was little, wherein I had been hit by a motorcycle and thereby needed stitches, I was rather curious as to what life would ...
more

Magnet Therapy? - Nov 19
There was an article in the New York Times a week or two ago about magnet therapy as a possible treatment for arthritis pain. Based on the idea that the magnets ...
more

Mayor Menino and his Knee... - Nov 10
A recent news article featuring Mayor Thomas M. Menino and his knee injury/surgery got me thinking. Since when are health problems considered to be public knowledge?  It ...
more

Athletes and ACL Injuries - Nov 03
Knee injuries can be very devastating to someone, especially if they happen to lead very active lives.  I'm not saying that lazy people who injure their knees aren't ...
more

Numero Uno - Oct 06
So I decided that today would be a good day to start blogging about the knees. "Why?" you ask? Well, it's quite simple actually.. why not?  I thought it was time... ...
more

It's all about the Bee's Knees

Magnet Therapy?
Posted: Nov 19, 2009 18:01:36 2 Comments.
  • Report this Post
  • Comment on this Post
  • magnet

    painkillers

    There was an article in the New York Times a week or two ago about magnet therapy as a possible treatment for arthritis pain. Based on the idea that the magnets help to "stimulate the release of the body's natural painkillers or by increasing blood flow to the tissue", magnetic straps and bracelets have become fashionable and popular.  However, this article points out that rarely do studies actually provide evidence to support this view.  In fact, the article cites that "in recent years a number of studies have found little evidence that they provide any real benefit", and then in a "well-designed 16-week study" published this year, researchers found that after comparing the effects various types of magnetic devices on people with osteoarthritis, their results "indicate that magnetic and copper bracelets are generally ineffective for managing pain, stiffness and physical function in osteoarthritis."

    However, I know plenty of people who would argue otherwise.  People who swear by the fact that their magnetic bracelet helped relieve the pain that wouldn't go away with OTC medication.. and I don't think they would lie about that.. why would they?

    It's amazing how effective the placebo effect can be... Personally, I don't see a problem with letting people believe that the magnets are helping; if the person believes that it's working..  Forget the saying "seeing is believing".. Obviously it would be more accurate to say that "believing is the first step to seeing".. or something along those lines.  If people want to believe that magnet therapy is an effective form of treatment for arthritis pain and this belief is not negatively affecting their health (or further harming them) in any way, let them be.  Let them believe..

     

  • Comment on this Post

  • Sort By

    Comments (2):
    By: amanda11: Dec, 23, 2009 12:55 PM

    When I started to read your post I thought - "I wonder if there is a placebo effect involved here?" And sure enough--you thought the same thing.

    I tend to agree with you and abide by the basic philosophy - "whatever works." If someone is in pain and can relieve that with medication, therapy, or something more psychological--they should do it. I think it's easy to turn to new medication or technology with the hopes that there will be an insta-cure. When, in fact, it takes a healthy dose of mental preparation and awareness to feel better regardless of what medication you're taking. Who's to say exactly which exact combination of positive-thinking, medicine, daily routine, general healthfulness. and even luck or timing is the best? Everyone is different.

    I think the idea of alternative medicine (magnets, et al.) is definitely worth the focus. Why? Because it's often natural and inexpensive--which is huge. So many people cannot afford treatments due to insurance or availability. If something simpler and more cost-effective works--people should go for it.  As long as a patient has a conversation with their doctor(s) and does ample research I think they're taking the most important steps to healing anyway.

    Thanks for sharing this!

    -Amanda


    By: Notyetagolfpro: Nov, 24, 2009 12:30 PM

    Well, given that our bodies are electromagnetic, this approach makes some sense to me.   There is a thousands of year old tradition in Chinese medicine of healing or alieviatig pain - including in the knee joint - by using acupuncture or herbs to channel blocked electromagnetic energy along lines known as meridien lines...



    Bookmark and Share



    Add tags for this Post (separated by commas):

    (Maximum characters: 50)
    You have characters left.
                                    

    Related posts:

  • Previous Blog Post
  • Next Blog Post

  • Forgot information?


    Bionic knee for amputees
    Bionic Knee Research for Amputees
    Watch as physical therapists at the University of South Florida work with a new type of prosthetic knee that helps amputees walk more naturally. Research is conducted with ...
    more more Featured Videos

    Dr. Cynthia LaBella
     

    Dr. Cynthia LaBella:
    Preventing Knee Injuries in Young Athletes

    more more Heroes
    Nominate a Hero Hero Policy
    Home | About Us | Press | Make a Suggestion | Content Syndication | Terms of Service
    Privacy Policy | Advertising Policy | Editorial Policy
    Last updated: Dec 11, 2009  ©1999- 2010 Body1, Inc. All rights reserved.